Lions Should Protect Their Assets in Cutler Deal
NFL Picks | by Mike O'Hara | 04.1.2009/7:00AM
Post a comment below or e-mail Mike O’Hara at
If the Lions are going to dive into the trade market and attempt to land Denver Broncos quarterback Jay Cutler, they have to protect their plan to build for the future at the same time they acquire a quarterback for the present.
Cutler was put on the trading block Tuesday night by Broncos owner Pat Bowlen, after nearly two weeks of fruitless attempts by the franchise to contact Cutler.
Cutler has been upset since learning that the Broncos tried to acquire former Patriots quarterback Matt Cassel. Cassel wound up in Kansas City, but the Broncos’ attempt created an irreparable split with Cutler.
The Lions have more than enough assets – chiefly, the first pick in this month’s draft and some other high picks – to make a deal for Cutler. But they cannot simply keep dumping draft picks on the pile until the Broncos finally cave and give them Cutler.
The Lions also have the 20th pick overall, the first pick on the second round and two third-round picks. How many of those picks would the Broncos want? Great question, and the answer will come when the bidding starts with other interested parts such as the Jets, Bucs and Bears.
If I were Lions GM Martin Mayhew, I’d stand pat and take Georgia quarterback Matt Stafford with the first pick.
But if the trade is going to be made, there has to be a way to make it more palatable.
If the Broncos insist on the first pick overall – to guarantee drafting Stafford – then the Lions should counter by asking for the Broncos’ first—round pick – No. 12 overall – in return as a starting point.
That won’t balance the deal for the Broncos. They’ll still need more. I’d offer the lower the Lions two third-round picks this year, and a third or fourth next year.
Still no deal? Then how about a player – defensive end Dewayne White, but withdrawing one of the draft picks from this year.
That would make the package look like this: The Lions get Cutler and the 12th pick on the first round. The Broncos get the first pick overall, Dewayne White and a third-round pick next year.
The Lions might have to add to the package – but nothing more from this year’s draft class.
They have to give Jim Schwartz, their new head coach, the tools to build a foundation. That cannot be done by stripping out the draft picks just to get a quarterback – especially one who apparently is as thin-skinned as Cutler, and who has never been a winner in college or the NFL.
If the Lions don’t trade for Cutler, they’re still sitting in a good spot – with all their draft picks this year, and the opportunity to draft Stafford, a young quarterback who wants to play in Detroit.
The bottom line: the old like that some of the best trades are the ones you don’t make fits the Lions right now as the Cutler sweepstakes begin.
Comments [16] |
Stafford Sizzles, Nails Status as Top QB Prospect
NFL Picks | by Mike O'Hara | 03.31.2009/6:25PM
Post a comment or e-mail Mike O’Hara at
They came, they saw – he conquered.
Matt Stafford erased any doubt about his status as the top quarterback in this year’s draft by delivering what one source called a “flawless” performance in a private workout Tuesday for the Lions.
The Lions have the first pick in the draft, and Stafford is one of the players under consideration.
Other candidates are offensive tackles Jason Smith of Baylor and Eugene Monroe of Virginia, and linebacker Aaron Curry of Wake Forest.
The Lions have made Daunte Culpepper their starting quarterback. Currently, only Drew Stanton and Drew Henson are on the roster as backups.
If Stafford’s performance Tuesday does not convince the Lions to draft him, then the logical conclusion is that they never intended to take a quarterback with the first pick overall, preferring to get a player at another position who can provide immediate help.
That, of course, would ignore their 51-year search to settle the position – with only one Pro Bowl performance by a Lions quarterback in that span of ineptitude.
Stafford was impressive at the University of Georgia’s pro-day workout earlier in the month, but Tuesday’s drills were deemed more important because of the nature of the workout.
At his pro day, which included other draft-eligible prospects from the school, Stafford was in charge of setting up the workout.
The Lions were in charge Tuesday. They put him through their own drills, and had said in advance that they wanted to put Stafford in uncomfortable situations to see how he would react.
According to reports by Si.com and ESPN’s Chris Mortensen, Stafford aced the workout, throwing between 40 and 50 passes, with only three incompletions.
The Lions are scheduled to attend Southern Cal’s pro day today. Quarterback Matt Sanchez, another first-round prospect, will work out. The Lions have asked to put Sanchez through an additional 30-minute session after the pro-day workout.
Sanchez is not rated in Stafford’s class.
Comments [8] |
